One of the most persistent and infuriating myths in anti-Israel circles is the claim that "Israel stole the land from the Palestinians." It's portrayed as if Jews showed up in 1948 like European invaders, forcibly expelled millions of Arabs from their homes, and seized their properties in some organized theft. This simplistic narrative completely ignores the complex history: legal land purchases, the UN partition plan, wars initiated by the Arab side, Jewish refugees expelled from Arab countries, and repeated Palestinian rejections of peace offers. It's as absurd as claiming the Palestinians "stole" the land from the Byzantines, Crusaders, or Ottomans: selective, ridiculous, and rooted in ignorance or deliberate hatred. This myth fuels propaganda visuals like the infamous "disappearing Palestine" maps, turning a tragic, two-sided conflict into a one-sided tale of Jewish "land theft."
Let's dismantle this lie with straightforward historical facts.
Before 1948, most land in Palestine wasn't privately owned by Arabs. Under Ottoman and British rule, 70-80% was state land (miri) or owned by absentee Arab landlords living in Beirut, Damascus, or Cairo. Jews, through organizations like the Jewish National Fund (JNF), bought land legally: registered contracts, high payments (often 10 times market value). From 1882 to 1948, Jews acquired about 7% of the land privately, mostly swamps, deserts, and uncultivated areas. They drained the Hadera marshes, irrigated the Jezreel Valley, and turned barren land into productive farms. No "theft" here: just lawful purchases, often from Arab sellers happy to offload problematic property.
In 1947, the UN proposed partition: a Jewish state on 55% (mostly the Negev desert), an Arab state on 45%, and international Jerusalem. Jews accepted, despite the fragmented, small territory. Arab leaders, under Haj Amin al-Husseini, rejected it and launched war, backed by Arab states. They urged local Arabs to flee temporarily so armies could "drive the Jews into the sea." In the 1948 War of Independence, around 700,000 Arabs became refugees: some fled in fear, some were expelled in battles (like Lydda and Ramle), but many left at their leaders' encouragement. Meanwhile, about 850,000 Jews were expelled from Arab countries, their property confiscated; they arrived in Israel as refugees. No one calls that "stolen land."
By 1949, Israel controlled 78% after winning a defensive war. Abandoned villages became state land, empty homes housed Jewish refugees. Tragic? Yes. Planned theft? No: war's outcome. Many Palestinians who stayed became Israeli citizens with equal rights (at least legally). The myth ignores Arab expulsions of Jews from Hebron, Gaza, Nablus.
In 1967's Six-Day War, Jordan, Egypt, and Syria attacked (or threatened); Israel captured Judea/Samaria, Gaza, Sinai, Golan in defense. Again, not "theft" but defensive conquest. Settlements cover 2-3% of Judea/Samaria: controversial, yes, but not wholesale theft. Israel returned Sinai for peace with Egypt, offered returns in Camp David 2000 and Annapolis 2008: Palestinians rejected.
The "disappearing Palestine" maps? Visual lies. The first (1946) marks Jewish private land as "Palestinian," ignoring state land. "Palestine" was never a sovereign Arab state: British Mandate, before that Ottoman. No theft from a non-existent country.
The real ugliness: portraying Jews as colonial thieves, ignoring ancient Jewish ties (Bible, Second Temple, continuous communities) and Jewish refugee status. Hypocritical too: Arab empires conquered vast lands, expelled peoples: no calls to return it all. Only Israel faces "theft" accusations. Part of modern antisemitism: singling out Israel, denying Jewish self-determination.
Deeper facts: 1945 British survey: only 8.6% Arab private ownership, 3.6% Jewish, rest state/public. Jews bought mostly from effendis, not fellahin. Many 1948 abandoned villages on legally bought or war-abandoned land. "Absentee Property" law used abandoned assets: harsh, but common in wars.
Impact: Fuels hate, justifies terror as "resistance," blocks peace. If everything's "stolen," no compromise. Yet history shows Israeli/Jewish peace offers (1937 Peel, 1947 UN, 2000 Barak, 2008 Olmert): all rejected. Palestinians demanded "right of return" to end Israel as Jewish state.
Scholars like Benny Morris (The Birth of the Palestinian Refugee Problem) or Efraim Karsh show refugee crisis from war, not organized expulsion (except isolated cases). Groups like CAMERA or JNS debunk fake maps.
Bottom line: "Stolen land" is a dumb, dangerous lie. It oversimplifies a two-sided tragedy, ignores facts, breeds hate. Spreaders aren't seeking peace: they deny Israel's existence. Time for real history: complex, tragic conflict, not simple "theft." Solution needs mutual recognition, not myths.
Sources and Further Reading Land Ownership in Palestine 1880-1948 Israel and the Myth of 'Stolen Land' The 'Stolen Land' Lie Myths & Facts: The Refugees Disappearing Palestine Maps Debunked
Comments
Post a Comment