Every Conspiracy Eventually Blames the Jews

 By גילי (גיל עד) כהן



There is a sentence I find myself repeating quite often: In every conspiracy theory, the villain eventually turns out to be a Jew.

This week, I asked myself honestly: Every single one? Really?

A sentence repeated often enough starts to sound like a fact. So I decided to check, one by one.

Let's start with the obvious ones.

The blood libel needs no introduction. It was built around Jews from day one. A Christian child, blood, Passover matzah.

In Trento, northern Italy, in 1475, a young boy named Simon was found dead. The city's Jews were tortured and executed. A cult grew around him as a supposed saint, and the Catholic Church only abolished his veneration in 1965.

The Black Death is more interesting.

A plague is a natural disaster. It has no villain. Yet on February 14, 1349, around 2,000 Jews were burned alive in Strasbourg, accused of poisoning wells. The plague had not even reached the city yet. When it eventually arrived, around 16,000 people died. The Jews were already gone, so they could no longer be blamed.

The city's chronicler wrote a sentence I cannot get out of my head:

"Money was what killed the Jews."

The plague was merely the excuse. Jewish property was the deeper reason.

The Protocols of the Elders of Zion are an even more straightforward case. A forgery produced in Russia in the early twentieth century to supposedly prove that Jews controlled the world.

So far, easy.

Then I reached the part where I thought my argument might fall apart.

Freemasons and the Illuminati.

The Illuminati was a Bavarian secret society founded in 1776 by a law professor named Adam Weishaupt. It was dissolved less than ten years later.

There were no Jews involved.

In 1797, a French priest named Augustin Barruel published a massive book blaming the Freemasons and the Illuminati for the French Revolution. Again, no Jews.

I had finally found a conspiracy theory without Jews. I thought that was the end of the story.

Nine years later, in 1806, Barruel received a letter from an officer named Simonini. The letter "revealed" that the people behind both the Freemasons and the Illuminati were Jews.

From there, the story took off.

The Protocols portrayed Freemasonry as a tool controlled by Jews. Throughout his rule, Franco spoke of a "Judeo-Masonic-Communist conspiracy."

In 1991, evangelical preacher Pat Robertson published a bestseller about the "New World Order," placing the Rothschild family at its center.

The conspiracy theory wasn't born Jewish. It simply couldn't manage to stay that way.

QAnon and the Cabal

Here I need to be fair. Even the Anti-Defamation League (ADL) acknowledges that most QAnon theories do not explicitly focus on Jews.

It started with Hillary Clinton and a Washington pizzeria.

But listen to the central story: a secret elite kidnaps children and extracts a substance from their blood that supposedly extends life.

That's the blood libel, almost word for word.

In 2022, social media users shared images of a statue of that same Simon of Trent, the boy from 1475, as "proof" that it was really happening.

It didn't take much effort for George Soros and the Rothschilds to enter the story too.

COVID-19

A virus from China. Nothing to do with Jews.

The Kantor Center at Tel Aviv University reviewed antisemitism in 2020 and identified one of that year's dominant themes: claims that Jews and Israelis had created the virus in order to sell the vaccine.

Pfizer CEO Albert Bourla is a Jew from Thessaloniki. Moderna's chief scientist, Tal Zaks, is Israeli. That was enough.

At anti-vaccine demonstrations across Europe, people appeared wearing yellow stars with the words "Unvaccinated" written on them.

The microchips

Here, I genuinely couldn't find a Jew.

Most of this story revolves around Bill Gates.

But give it time. It will get there.

So I need to revise my original statement.

Not every conspiracy theory starts with a Jew. Some start with a French priest, a pizzeria, or a virus from China.

But almost every conspiracy theory that grows large enough eventually arrives at the same address.

The villain isn't always Jewish at the beginning.

But almost always by the end.

That's my litmus test.

When I read a theory and find Jews standing at the top of the pyramid, I know I'm not reading some groundbreaking revelation. I'm reading a blood libel in a new disguise.

You could say these are just stupid posts on the internet.

I wanted to believe that too. So I looked into how many Americans actually believe these things.

In 2013, 28% of Americans believed a secret elite was planning to take over the world through a "New World Order."

In 2020, another 28% believed Bill Gates wanted to implant microchips in people through vaccines.

In 2021, 15% agreed that the US government, media, and financial world were controlled by a satanic cult of pedophiles.

By 2023, that figure had reached 25%.

One in four Americans.

Here I had to stop, because I came across a study that didn't fit my assumptions.

Researchers at the University of Miami examined dozens of conspiracy theories over half a century and found that Americans had not, overall, become more conspiratorial.

Some theories gain popularity, others disappear, and the overall pool remains roughly the same size.

So perhaps the number of conspiracy believers isn't growing.

What's changing is the target.

A massive survey of more than 120,000 Americans found that 37% were highly prone to conspiratorial thinking. Among them, the likelihood of embracing antisemitic stereotypes was almost three times higher than among everyone else.

The ADL reached the same conclusion from another direction: of all the factors they examined, conspiratorial thinking was the strongest predictor of antisemitism. Even stronger than Holocaust denial.

The pool of conspiracy believers remains roughly the same. What's growing is the proportion of conspiracy theories that eventually end up blaming Jews.

Every conspiracy needs someone at the top of the pyramid. We Jews have had 2,000 years of experience playing that role.

What does this mean for Jews in real life?

In 2025, the ADL recorded 6,274 antisemitic incidents in the United States. That's 17 a day. It was fewer than the record set in 2024, but five

Comments